Brandeis Brief: Highlights from Harvard, NYU, Georgetown, Texas, and other battlegrounds

Brandeis Brief: June 2022

This month, the Brandeis Center doubled down on its efforts to preserve free speech, while reminding universities they should use their own voices to condemn anti-Semitism with the same vigor and clarity they use to denounce hate speech against other minority groups.
  • LDB Chairman Kenneth L. Marcus authored a high-profile Washington Post op-ed exposing Georgetown University’s inconsistency in condemning the speech of speakers with which it disagrees but remaining silent in the face of anti-Semitic hate speech.
  • LBD partnered with the Silicon Valley Chinese Association Foundation on a legal brief for the Supreme Court’s high-profile Harvard case. Kenneth L. Marcus followed up the brief with an op-ed for the New York Sun.
  • Marcus addressed ‘Anti-Semitism in Higher Education’ at the Academic Engagement Network’s annual conference. He opened his speech with crucial thought leadership about the anti-Semitic conspiratorial worldview connecting the dots between the Buffalo Massacre’s white supremacist killer, the NYC subway shooter’s black supremacist attacker, and Colleyville’s Islamist terrorist. Jewish Journal published Marcus’s op-ed on this topic the next day.
  • LDB President Alyza Lewin headlined a Maryland synagogue congregation’s law day lecture, with a speech titled ‘Is Today’s Campus Climate Safe for Jews?’
  • The Jewish Journal highlighted a brief jointly filed by LDB and Hadassah urging the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals to uphold a Texas law prohibiting anti-Israel boycotts. Marcus penned an op-ed on the topic for the Washington Times.
  • LDB’s work addressing the rising problem of workplace antisemitism was the foundation for an exposé by the Society for Human Resource Management.
  • Kenneth L. Marcus was featured on a News 12 Network segment investigating campus anti-Semitism and questioning whether schools are reporting incidents accurately.
  • LDB joined Nebraska Gov. Pete Ricketts, the Combat Antisemitism Movement, Conference of Presidents, Weitzman National Museum of American Jewish History, American Jewish Committee, and Hadassah in a ceremony commemorating Jewish American Heritage Month.
  • The New York Sun interviewed Marcus for a story about the federal scrutiny of anti-Semitism at NYU.
Read about these and other developments at the Center in this month’s Brief. As always, we thank you for your tax-deductible donations and acknowledge that without you our work could not be done.

LDB Urges Georgetown to ‘Listen, Learn, and Lead’

Founder and Chairman Kenneth L. Marcus followed up LDB’s Georgetown letter with a high-profile Washington Post op-ed calling upon the university to “Listen, learn, and lead.”

  • Listen to Jewish students who describe the harm they face when Georgetown Law Center brings anti-Semitic speakers to campus.
  • Learn about the forms that anti-Semitism takes on college campuses today, including left-wing, right-wing, and anti-Zionist anti-Semitism.
  • Lead by speaking out, using the university’s own freedom of speech to condemn anti-Semitism promptly, firmly, and specifically, as well as by adopting policies that reflect current law, including the Executive Order on Combating Anti-Semitism.

Marcus reminded the university that “it has its free speech rights – and those rights encompass the freedom to condemn racism, anti-Semitism and discrimination in all its forms. And Georgetown must do just that.”

LDB turned Marcus’s words into a social media campaign, earning praise from Palestinian human rights activist Bassem Eid.

LDB Briefs Supreme Court on Discrimination against Jewish and Asian American Applicants

LDB teamed up with the Silicon Valley Chinese Association Foundation (SVCAF) on a U.S. Supreme Court brief in support of Asian American students in the Harvard affirmative action case, Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard. Together, we showed the Court that an admissions program developed by Harvard a century ago to limit the enrollment of Jewish students is now being used to limit the enrollment of Asian American students. Kenneth L. Marcus followed up the brief with an op-ed on the topic for the New York Sun.

Kenneth L. Marcus Addresses ‘Anti-Semitism in Higher Education’ at AEN National Conference

Kenneth L. Marcus presented at the Academic Engagement Network National Conference May 18 on “Anti-Semitism in Higher Education: Educational and Legal Approaches.” Along with his participation on a Federalist Society panel, ‘Selective Enforcement of Civil Rights Law by the Administrative Agencies,’ the events marked his return to in-person speaking since the start of the pandemic.

Marcus began his AEN speech with remarks about the common factor uniting recent terror attacks in Buffalo, a New York City subway and Colleyville, Texas. The perpetrators of all three attacks were driven by a Jewish conspiracy theory worldview – even when the primary targets were not Jewish, as in Buffalo and New York. And in each case the anti-Semitism involved was downplayed – even when the targets were Jews attacked during synagogue prayer, as in Colleyville.

He expanded upon this idea the following day in a Jewish Journal op-ed:

“Three different races and three different mindsets….Yet their ideas were unified and made murderous by the same central principle: the age-old conspiratorial fantasy that Jews are an all-powerful cabal who are responsible for all the world’s evils…. In all three cases, the antisemitic element has been ignored, downplayed or misunderstood. And yet the failure to grasp this problem has endangered members of all communities.”

Click the image to view Kenneth L. Marcus’s full AEN speech on
‘Anti-Semitism in Higher Education.’
LDB President Alyza Lewin Headlines Synagogue Law Day Lecture

Brandeis Center President Alyza Lewin was the featured speaker at the Law Day Lecture for the Ohr Kodesh Congregation, a synagogue in Chevy Chase, Maryland. The event marked Lewin’s return to in-person speaking engagements since the start of the pandemic.

A leading voice in the fight against anti-Semitism on college campuses, Lewin addressed the problems being faced by Jewish students, faculty, and staff today and how to use the law to protect members of the Jewish community on campus and beyond.

LDB recently added two other notable Lewin videos to LDB’s revamped YouTube channel – her remarks before a 2019 U.S. Justice Department panel on combating anti-Semitism and the Combat Anti-Semitism Movement’s new #MeetOurPartner video.

Click the image to view Alyza Lewin explain that anti-Israel activity on campus is not debate and dialogue – but part of a concerted effort to shun Jewish students unless they shun the part of their Jewish identity that defines them as part of the Jewish people – with a connection to the land of Israel.
LDB Brief in Texas Case Covered by Jewish Journal; Marcus Pens Op-ed for Washington Times

The Brandeis Center’s jointly filed legal brief with Hadassah – urging a federal court of appeals to reverse a lower court’s ruling invalidating a Texas law discouraging anti-Israel boycotts – was featured prominently in Jewish Journal’s coverage of the story.

Kenneth L. Marcus told the Journal: “We are arguing that what the state of Texas has done is simply to condition government contracts on an agreement not to engage in discriminatory conduct. It is fairly standard to place conditions on government contracts – including discriminatory provisions – and what we’re saying is there should not be an Israel exception.”

If the appeals court were to side with the lower court, it would “create a terrible precedent,” Marcus stated. “It would create an Israel exception to anti-discrimination law that could be used against Jewish Americans, not just in government contracting but on college campuses, in the workplace and elsewhere.” He added: “The reasoning that the Court uses could be used to deny the notion that BDS is anti-Semitic and that the so-called ‘new anti-Semitism’ is a form of bigotry.”

Marcus followed up the article with an op-ed published in the Washington Times: “Texas is not legally required to subsidize any other form of discrimination. There is no justification for a rule that applies differently to antisemitism than to other forms of hate.”

Landmark Workplace Anti-Semitism Article by SHRM Features Kenneth L. Marcus as Linchpin

LDB’s work has traditionally focused on college campuses, but we are increasingly seeing anti-Semitism seep into the corporate world. We addressed workplace anti-Semitism in our Stanford case and an important webinar featuring EEOC Commissioners Andrea Lucas and Keith Sonderling.

Our work has caught the attention of important figures in the human resources community, including Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion editor Matt Gonzales of the Society for Human Resource Management. In a new article, Gonzales describes the growing problem of corporate anti-Semitism, and quotes LDB Chairman Kenneth L. Marcus.

News 12 Network Investigates Under-reporting of Campus Anti-Semitic Incidents; Interviews Marcus

New York City regional cable network News 12 completed a months-long investigation into whether U.S. universities are intentionally underreporting campus anti-Semitic incidents. The story includes an interview with Marcus – and statistics from LDB’s 2021 ‘Anti-Semitism @ College’ poll – the first to survey openly Jewish college students.

Click image to view News 12 Network segment: ‘Watchdogs: Jewish students often target of hate, bias on U.S. college campuses.’
LDB Co-Sponsors First Nebraska Event
The Brandeis Center co-sponsored an event with Nebraska Governor Pete Ricketts along with the Combat Antisemitism Movement, Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations, the Weitzman National Museum of American Jewish History, the American Jewish Committee and Hadassah. Gov. Ricketts inaugurated May as Jewish American Heritage Month – a first for any U.S. State. He also officially adopted the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) Working Definition of Anti-Semitism, making it the 26th state to do so. Nebraska’s endorsement means the majority of US states have now adopted the IHRA Definition.
Marcus Urges Continued Federal Monitoring of Anti-Semitism at NYU

Kenneth L. Marcus was interviewed for a New York Sun article examining the Title VI monitoring of NYU after years of ignored anti-Semitic incidents. The Dept. of Education’s Office for Civil Rights is set to end their monitoring of NYU on May 31, and Marcus argued this would be a poor decision: “The Biden administration can’t close its eyes to what is happening at NYU.” Marcus identified recent emails from NYU’s Students for Justice in Palestine chapter and other student groups as “massively anti-Semitic” and part of a larger pattern of administrative malpractice whereby NYU “has not been effective in how it has addressed anti-Semitism.”

Donate to the Brandeis Center
The Louis D. Brandeis Center
1717 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW, Suite 1025, Washington, DC 20006

You can update your preferences or unsubscribe from this list.
The Louis D. Brandeis Center is a nonprofit organization supported by individuals, groups and foundations that share our concern about Jewish college students.  Contributions are tax-exempt under section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code.  To support our efforts to combat campus anti-Semitism, please contact us at info@brandeiscenter.com
Twitter
Instagram
Facebook
Website
YouTube
Email